October 6, 2022
Chicago 12, Melborne City, USA
Top Stories

Tale of two V-P farewells: PM Modi praised Venkaiah Naidu, mocked Hamid Ansari | India News


NEW DELHI: The five-year time period of M Venkaiah Naidu as vice-president and ex-officio chairman of Rajya Sabha on Monday got here to an finish with senior leaders heaping lavish reward on him. Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s beneficiant compliments have been additionally a reminder of the way by which he had criticised Naidu’s predecessor Hamid Ansari nearly 5 years in the past.
Naidu was bid farewell by MPs on the final day of Rajya Sabha’s monsoon session. MPs of a number of political events paid wealthy tributes to the outgoing chairman of the Higher Home in the course of the farewell speech.
Whereas making his speech first, PM Modi spoke for shut to twenty minutes. In distinction, he spoke for barely 5 minutes in the course of the farewell of Ansari on August 10, 2017, the day the latter retired after serving as V-P and Rajya Sabha chairman for 2 consecutive phrases.
Ansari was solely the second V-P in impartial India’s historical past to serve for 2 consecutive phrases. The primary was India’s first V-P Sarvapalli Radhakrishnan, who was on the chair from 1952 to 1962.
PM Modi on Venkaiah Naidu
Collaborating within the farewell within the Rajya Sabha on August 8, the prime minister remembered many moments that have been marked by the knowledge and wit of Naidu. He famous the change of complexion of management in fashionable India and stated, “Once we mark fifteenth August this yr, will probably be an Independence Day when the president, vice-president, speaker and prime minister would have been born after independence. And that too, every of them belongs to quite simple backgrounds.”
Modi recalled Naidu’s contribution for the youth of the nation. “As our vice-president, you devoted loads of time to youth welfare. Numerous your programmes have been centered on Yuva Shakti,” he stated and added that 25 per cent of Naidu’s speeches exterior the Home have been among the many youth of India.

PM Modi’s remarks throughout farewell ceremony of Vice President Venkaiah Naidu in Rajya Sabha

The PM appreciated Naidu’s ideological dedication as a celebration employee, as an MLA and as an MP; organisational expertise because the president of the BJP; his laborious work and diplomacy as Union minister and his dedication and dignity because the V-P and the chairman of the Higher Home.
“I’ve labored with M Venkaiah Naidu ji carefully over time. I’ve additionally seen him take up completely different duties and he carried out every of them with nice dedication,” he stated.
Modi additionally highlighted the wit, vocabulary and wordplay of Naidu. He stated, “Your every phrase is heard, most well-liked, and revered… and by no means countered. The one liners of Venkaiah Naidu ji are well-known. They’re wit liners. His command over the languages has all the time been nice.”
Modi additionally referred to Naidu’s humble beginnings in south India. He stated the V-P’s journey from a political employee to the president of the BJP was a mirrored image of his indomitable steadfastness in ideology and tenacity. “If now we have emotions for the nation, artwork of placing ahead our views, religion in linguistic range then language and area by no means grow to be obstacles for us and you’ve got proved this,” he stated.
The PM additional stated, “One of many admirable issues about Venkaiah ji is his ardour in the direction of Indian languages. This was mirrored in how he presided over the Home. He contributed to elevated productiveness of the Rajya Sabha.”
Modi made a particular point out of the elevated productiveness of the Higher Home as a result of techniques established by Naidu. Throughout his tenure as Rajya Sabha chairman, productiveness of the Home elevated by 70 per cent, attendance of the members elevated, and a file 177 payments have been handed or mentioned. “You could have taken so many selections that might be remembered for the upward journey of the Higher Home,” he stated.
Lauding Naidu, the prime minister stated, “I see the maturity of democracy in your requirements” and praised his view of “let authorities suggest, let opposition oppose and let the home dispose”.
PM Modi’s farewell speech for Hamid Ansari
Modi had began with praising Ansari’s household background. He stated, “After a protracted service, I’m assured that right this moment you can be shifting in the direction of a brand new subject of labor as a result of bodily you have got saved your self match. A household whose historical past has been in public life for nearly a 100 years. Your maternal grandfather, your grandfather have been generally president of the Congress and generally have been within the Constituent Meeting. In a manner, you come from the background of a household whose ancestors have been in public life. Specifically, they’ve been lively within the Congress and generally with the Khilafat Motion.”
Subsequently, Modi took a dig at Ansari who was an Indian Overseas Service (IFS) officer earlier than he joined politics.
Modi stated, “Your personal life has been a profession diplomat. I understood what a profession diplomat is just after changing into PM. One can not instantly perceive the which means of their laughter and the best way they shake fingers. As a result of they’re educated on this. However using his expertise would positively have occurred right here in 10 years. In dealing with all this, how this talent would have benefitted this Home.”

PM Modi’s speech on the farewell to VP Shri Hamid Ansari

The PM roasted Ansari when he stated, “Most of your tenure has been related to West Asia as a diplomat. A few years of life have handed in that realm, in that setting, in that thought, in that debate and amongst these individuals. Even after retiring from there, most of your work largely remained the identical – be it the Minority Fee or Aligarh College. The circle remained the identical. However within the final 10 years, you have been entrusted with a separate process. Each second you have been tied throughout the limits of the Structure. You tried your greatest to shoulder that accountability.”
Modi stated maybe there would have been some restlessness inside Ansari for 10 lengthy years. “Nevertheless, that disaster won’t stay for you after right this moment. You’ll expertise the enjoyment of liberation. You’ll have the chance to behave, suppose and communicate in accordance with your fundamental pondering,” the PM stated.
Hamid Ansari’s reservations about PM Modi’s remarks
Ansari did take objection to Modi’s feedback throughout his farewell operate.
Virtually a yr later, Ansari stated many thought-about the PM’s feedback to be a departure from accepted follow on such events.
In July 2018, Ansari wrote it in his guide ‘Dare I Query? Reflections on Up to date Challenges’, which is a set of his speeches and writings, made largely in his final yr in workplace and for just a few months later.
“The prime minister participated on this and whereas being fulsome in his compliments additionally hinted at what he perceived to be a sure inclination in my strategy on account of my having spent, as he put it, each a great a part of my skilled tenure as a diplomat in Muslim lands and in post-retirement interval on minority-related questions.
“The context, presumably, was my reference within the Bengaluru speech to what I perceived as enhanced apprehension of insecurity and within the TV interview to a way of unease creeping in amongst Muslims and another non secular minorities,” Ansari wrote in his guide.
He additional wrote, “The next furore by the ‘trustworthy’ on social media tended to lend credence to this. Alternatively, editorial feedback and a great many critical writings thought-about the PM’s remarks to be a departure from accepted follow on such events.”

Supply hyperlink
#Story #farewells #Modi #praised #Venkaiah #Naidu #mocked #Hamid #Ansari #India #Information


Leave feedback about this

  • Quality
  • Price
  • Service


Add Field


Add Field
Choose Image
Choose Video